Is voice-to-text safe while driving? It is safer than typing a message by hand, because your eyes and hands can stay closer to the road and wheel. But research from the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety and the University of Utah shows that voice tasks still distract the mind, and the effect can last after you finish. In some systems tested, mental distraction lingered for up to 27 seconds.

Many states allow voice-to-text, so it is often legal. This guide explains what the research found and how to use voice features with the least risk.

Key findings

  • Composing a text or email by voice raised mental workload more than just listening to messages (AAA Foundation).
  • Mental distraction can last up to 27 seconds after a voice task in the worst-performing systems, and more than 15 seconds in the best (AAA Foundation, 2015).
  • In-vehicle infotainment tasks, including voice-based ones, distracted drivers for 17 to 40 seconds; older drivers were distracted longest (AAA, 2019).
  • Hands-free phone conversations reduced drivers’ attention to what was in front of them (Strayer et al., 2003).

What the AAA Foundation measured

In 2013, the AAA Foundation and University of Utah researchers developed a rating scale for the mental workload of common in-car tasks, from listening to the radio to composing an email by voice. The research challenged the assumption that a driver is safe as long as eyes are on the road and hands are on the wheel.

In two follow-up studies, they applied the scale to voice systems in cars and phones. One finding: allowing drivers to compose replies to texts and emails, rather than only listen to messages, raised the distraction level from category 2 to category 3 on the Foundation’s scale. Simple car commands, like adjusting the climate control, were less demanding. The researchers recommended limiting drivers’ access to high-demand functions and keeping menus short.

Why voice-to-text still distracts

Composing a message requires you to:

  • Decide what to say.
  • Speak it in a way the system will understand.
  • Listen to or glance at the result to check for errors.
  • Fix mistakes.

Each step takes attention from driving. That is cognitive distraction, and voice control does not remove it. When the system mishears you or the screen shows the text, visual distraction comes back too.

The distraction lasts after you finish

In 2015 research for the AAA Foundation, University of Utah researchers found that potentially unsafe mental distraction could last up to 27 seconds after a driver finished a voice task like dialing, changing music or sending a text, in the worst-performing systems tested. Even in the least distracting systems, drivers remained impaired for more than 15 seconds. At the 25 mph speed in the study, 27 seconds is nearly the length of three football fields.

Car infotainment systems

A 2019 AAA study tested voice-based and touch screen features in new vehicles. Drivers were visually and mentally distracted for 17 to 40 seconds when doing tasks like programming navigation or sending a text. Older drivers, ages 55 to 75, took their eyes and attention off the road more than eight seconds longer than younger drivers, ages 21 to 36. AAA recommended avoiding infotainment use while driving except for legitimate emergency or driving purposes. See our guides to ADAS and distracted driving and distracted driving and senior citizens.

Hands-free conversations

Phone calls, even hands-free, show a similar pattern. A 2003 simulator study by Strayer, Drews and Johnston found that hands-free conversations slowed drivers’ reactions to braking vehicles and reduced their attention to what was right in front of them. A 2006 study found that phone conversations, handheld or hands-free, impaired drivers as much as a 0.08 blood alcohol level in some measures. See how distracted driving affects your brain.

What the law says

Many state hands-free laws allow voice-to-text because it does not require holding the phone. For example:

  • Georgia allows voice-to-text, where spoken words are automatically converted to a written message (O.C.G.A. 40-6-241).
  • Tennessee allows adults to use voice-to-text (T.C.A. 55-8-199).
  • Mississippi excludes voice-operated or hands-free devices from its texting ban (Miss. Code 63-33-1).
  • Kansas excludes voice-operated texting that does not use either hand, except to turn a feature on or off (K.S.A. 8-15,111).

Teen drivers are often treated differently: GHSA reports that 36 states and DC ban all phone use, including hands-free, for novice drivers. Legal does not mean safe, and the research above is a reason to keep voice texting to a minimum. Check your state in our hands-free driving laws by state guide.

How to use voice features more safely

  1. Let messages wait. Turn on a driving mode with an auto-reply; see our Do Not Disturb While Driving setup guide.
  2. Listen rather than reply. Composing is more demanding than listening.
  3. Keep it short. If a reply needs more than a few words, pull over and park.
  4. Set navigation and music before you move.
  5. Avoid voice tasks in demanding traffic, such as merging, construction zones and intersections.
  6. Give your attention time to come back after any voice task.

Frequently asked questions

Is voice-to-text safer than typing while driving?

Yes, it reduces visual and manual distraction. But it still causes mental distraction, and research found the effect can last up to 27 seconds.

Is voice-to-text legal while driving?

In many states, yes, for adult drivers. Georgia, Tennessee, Mississippi and Kansas, for example, allow or exclude voice-operated texting. Many states ban all phone use for teen drivers.

Is listening to messages safer than replying?

AAA Foundation research found that composing replies raised the distraction level compared with only listening.

Are car voice systems safer than phones?

It depends on the system. AAA’s 2019 study found in-vehicle tasks distracted drivers for 17 to 40 seconds, with older drivers affected most.

What is the safest option?

Silence the phone with a driving mode and handle messages after you park.

Sources

Last reviewed: November 5, 2026


TextingWithDriving.com is professionally built and maintained to ensure accurate, accessible safety information reaches every driver who needs it. Website development and ongoing support is handled by Budgetic, a digital agency specializing in purpose-driven WordPress websites.

Leave a Reply